Unsurprisingly, our roundtable event also led us to discuss how to be sure when you think you’ve found great talent. I was curious to see how this question would be answered by each of the Creative Directors amongst their peers. Any junior out there trying to impress at their next interview should read on:

Peter Bidenko of Leo Burnett got the ball rolling on this one, indicating that at the junior level he’s more focused on enthusiasm. “The more senior they are the more I want to probe into how strategic they are and what they have actually done.”

Mark Bamfield former long termer at TBWA and new ECD of Y&R Jordan had this to offer, “Can they think? Take them out of their comfort zones and challenge them to think and articulate new ideas.”

Similarly, Ben Knight ECD OgilvyAction Dubai is also looking for people who can demonstrate their own creativity; “People that can talk comfortably about a good piece of work lets you know they came up with it.”

Mark Bamfield continued with the same theme, “I like to just hear people talk about their work. Putting the website and portfolio aside – we need to revert to getting them to describe an idea as well as show it.”

Adding to these views, Ryan Reed of Y&R went a step further to talk about the type of individual he looks for; “It’s about the personal side as much as about what’s in their portfolio. I want to know what inspires their creativity. Without personal there’s no passion. In some ways I like to see potential over achievement.”

Tim Styles the new ECD at The Agency, Doha and former CD at M&C Saatchi London confirmed the importance of personality, concluding “It’s about two things: energy and curiosity. I want to see people show a burning interest in something. It’s about character – an unwritten rule for creatives. People that creep up on you with hidden depth are preferable to those who are trained and overt. I prefer people who are like truffles-it ain’t obvious.”

I hope that has given the next Frank Lowe amongst you a few tips…

Creative, creative director, ECD, Executive Creative Director, Leo Burnett, M&C Saatchi, Ogilvy, TBWA, Y&R

Welcome to the first of a series of three posts taken from a recent roundtable dinner event that we held with a number of our clients in the creative industry. Our first topic for discussion was opportunities for women in advertising.

Noticing the gender imbalance around the table over dinner, Ryan Reed, ECD at Y&R Dubai noted that gender prejudice in advertising is a “non-issue” citing Nadine Ghoussoub, current Y&R General Manager as evidence of this.

In addition, Ms. Komal Bedi Sohal, a Creative Director at Y&R Dubai is one of the regions most awarded and innovative creatives. She won a Gold Lion at Cannes this year thus proving that Middle Eastern women are receiving the highest accolades on advertising’s biggest,  global stage. Check out her work! http://komalbedisohal.com/”

However, Adam Obeid, Regional Creative Director of JWT Dubai pointed out; “The demands of the region dictate the gender bias.  The biggest market in the Gulf is KSA and we all know the challenges of hiring females in that part of the world.”

A German senior creative living in the Gulf commented from her experience working in Cape Town, London and Dubai: “Women have to work harder in this region to achieve recognition.”  As a recruiter specialising in this market, it is undeniable that there are few women in the market, particularly in senior roles but that raises another interesting point  voiced by Peter Bidenko, Executive Creative Director, Leo Burnett Dubai, “The work-life balance in advertising makes is difficult for some mothers to stay in the industry.”

After recruiting solely for advertising roles in the Gulf, I have never worked with a company that would prefer a male candidate over a female candidate.  The only time gender has been relevant is within KSA where this is a cultural issue for women nationally when it comes to work rather than an industry specific problem.  I firmly believe that advertising provides equal career opportunities for men and women.  Regarding countries where women’s rights are less advanced, Morgan McKinley works with creative professionals from different backgrounds and locations to help them find opportunities across the UAE.  We work with a number of industry ‘heavy weights’ and are always interested to hear from those interested in a move in advertising.

creative director, JWT, Leo Burnett, Y&R